Use of very general tags like "professors", "students", and "university"

Question

I would like to clarify under what conditions questions should be tagged with certain very general tags, such as professors, students, and university.

These tags convey meaningful information in certain situations; for example, it makes sense to tag a question about professors' salaries with professors.

But given that a huge portion of questions on this site involve students and/or professors doing something in a university setting, it seems to me that without very specific guidelines for applying these tags, they have the potential to be overused to the point of being meaningless. For example, is there any benefit to tagging a question about an authorship dispute between PhD students with professors, students, and phd?

Can anyone offer specific guidelines on how to apply these and other very general tags so that they will be useful?

Answer 1

I think the problem is more general than just those specific tags.

I would be extremely interested in usage statistics of our tags. Not how often tags are being used for questions, but how often somebody actually searches for a specific tag. My underlying assumption is that many of our tags are essentially useless, as they are so general, and their use so ill-defined, that nobody actually uses them for their intended purpose (to find questions fitting their interest). For instance, I can hardly imagine the person that would be interested in questions tagged phd, but not all other questions on academia.SE.

To address your concrete question:

Can anyone offer specific guidelines on how to apply these and other very general tags so that they will be useful?

I cannot. What I would encourage, though, is a deeper discussion about how tags are being used in this stack exchange, and whether we can and should clean this up from ground up. I could, for instance, imagine having a smallish number of fixed tags, a la meta, with really well-defined semantics and which are only changed based on meta discussions.

Answer 2

I have been retagging some new and old questions lately and found much too many questions tagged with one of the mentioned tags, which do not even contain this word in title or body. Due to this, I think that the only way to keep these tags clean is to control every single new question.

Can anyone offer specific guidelines on how to apply these and other very general tags so that they will be useful?

When retagging, I have been going by the philosophy to keep those tags only, if they can be expected to be essential to the question or answer, for example, if the situation necessarily involves some of the respective persons to be a professor (and not just any supervisor) or if it was crucial that a university was involved and not a research lab or some other institution.

Answer 3

The "University" tag seems to be completely redundant. At least in British English, "academia" and "universities" are synonyms: it's impossible to ask a question about one that isn't a question about the other.