A recent question is wondering whether there exists any good forum for getting peer feedback on academic job application material. It was closed as a "shopping question," which I really do not understand.
I think that shopping questions are essentially of the form:
There are a whole bunch of academic things of this sort; can you tell me which one fits my needs?
This seems very different to me, since it's asking whether a rather general sort of resource (an online peer feedback environment for academics) exists at all. I think this is a good question and should be reopened.